Trustworthy and efficient AI · Doha, Qatar

Bekir Sait
Çiftler

Assistant Professor and Head of the Department of Data Science and Artificial Intelligence, University of Doha for Science and Technology (UDST)

How do systems keep working under partial information, limited resources and shifting conditions?

That question has run through my work for more than a decade, from wireless positioning to federated learning and deep reinforcement learning. Today I ask it of machine learning systems after deployment: how to mitigate data drift, concept drift and objective drift; how to keep models small enough to monitor; and how to tell when an AI agent has gone wrong.

Bekir Sait Çiftler

Research

One question across four settings

Each stage asked the same question with less to go on. First the measurements were incomplete; then the data could not be shared; then the budget was tight; then the world itself had moved.

  1. 2013–2017 · Ph.D., Florida International University, with NC State, MERL and QMIC

    Partial signals

    How do you locate a device, or count the people in a room, when GPS is gone and every reading is incomplete?

    What I did
    • Cramér–Rao bounds for RSS-based localization in passive UHF RFID, with 3-D antenna patterns.
    • Bistatic RFID localization: coverage up from 46% to 80% in simulation, with up to 84% of tags located to within 1 m.
    • Occupancy counting from Wi-Fi probe requests of 33,847 devices: zone accuracy up from 64% to 78%.

    Carried forward: inference from partial, noisy signals.

  2. 2019–2022 · Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Hamad Bin Khalifa University

    Unshared data

    How does a model learn from data it cannot see, sent by clients it cannot fully trust?

    What I did
    • Federated localization from crowdsourced RSS fingerprints, cutting error by 1.8 m when used to boost centralized training.
    • Federated mimic learning for intrusion detection, reaching 98.1% accuracy on NSL-KDD.
    • Reputation mechanisms based on deep reinforcement learning that pick reliable clients despite poisoning attacks, raising federated accuracy by more than 30%.

    Carried forward: deciding whom to trust without seeing the data.

  3. 2020–2024 · HBKU and UDST

    Scarce resources

    How should a system spend limited power, spectrum or time, one decision at a time, when the next state is unknown?

    What I did
    • A survey of deep reinforcement learning for resource management in heterogeneous wireless networks, my most cited work.
    • Hierarchical multi-agent DRL: a deep Q-network assigns radio-access technologies while multi-agent DDPG sets power.
    • DRL control of light fixtures, mirror arrays and reflecting surfaces for secure visible-light and mmWave links.

    Carried forward: sequential decisions under a budget.

  4. 2024–today · UDST

    Shifting conditions

    How do you keep a learning system working, and trustworthy, after the world it was trained on has moved on?

    What I did
    • Early-warning models for programming students, tested across terms, as a co-investigator on a QRDI project.
    • An agentic LLM framework that augments scarce labelled data for defect-report classification.
    • Vision-language models: a learned gate that feeds extra signals into a frozen model ends up closing, and conditioning on a specialist’s single count cuts crowd-counting MAE from 81.6 to 62.7.

    Now: the agenda below.

Current agenda

Keeping AI reliable after deployment

Efficiency, auditability and robustness to change are usually studied in separate literatures. In deployment they fail together: a model too large to run locally gets centralized, a centralized model is harder to inspect, and a model nobody inspects decays unnoticed. So I treat them as one problem and work through it as three questions, each leading to the next.

  1. Drift

    Which changes matter?

    Trained on one semester and tested on the next, every model lost between 5 and 33 points.

    Data drift, concept drift and objective drift need different responses. The third, where the link between inputs and outcomes holds but the goal changes, is common in practice and rarely studied. I ask which changes actually degrade decisions, and which maintenance policies carry over from simulation to real deployments.

  2. Small models

    What can afford to keep watching?

    A monitor that costs as much as the model it watches will never run continuously.

    Small models can be that monitor. I study what oversight needs from them: calibration, abstention and consistency under paraphrase, evaluated in Turkish and Arabic as well as English.

  3. Agents

    What happens when the alarm sounds?

    In a multi-agent pipeline, an error at step two becomes a fact by step seven.

    A monitor’s alarm only helps if something acts on it. I adapt the reputation mechanisms I built for federated learning to decide which agent outputs to trust, and treat the response to an alarm as a sequential decision under a cost budget.

Flagship project · the first question in practice

Every semester is a distribution shift

On a QRDI-funded project on AI-driven personalized learning and gamification in programming education, I worked with the team that forecast final-exam performance for 650 students in 36 sections, one month before the exam. I thank lead PI Dr. Seifeddine Bouallegue, as well as Dr. Abdullatif Shikfa and Dr. Aymen Omri.

Within a term, the best of six models exceeded 91% reported accuracy. Trained on Fall 2024 and tested on Winter 2025, every model lost between 5 and 33 points, and the ranking of the models changed.

Each term brings a new cohort, revised assessments and new tools. An early-warning model in education needs maintenance built in from the start.

Drop
XGBoost −7.5
Linear regression −14.4
Random forest −5.4
SVR −10.6
Decision tree −6.5
Neural network −33.3
Show the numbers
ModelWithin termNext termDrop
XGBoost91.2483.777.47
Linear regression90.0975.7114.38
Random forest89.6384.285.35
Support vector regression89.6178.9910.62
Decision tree88.8182.316.50
Neural network82.3148.9933.32

Final-exam forecasts from data available one month before the exam. Source: Bouallegue, Omri and Al-Naemi, Information 17(1), 60, 2026, a study from the QRDI project ARG01-0516-230182.

Funding

Funded research

AI-driven personalized learning and gamification in programming education QRDI · ARG01-0516-230182 Co-investigator · active
Adaptive non-invasive brain–computer interfaces QRDI · GSRA12-L-0420-250258 Primary research mentor · active

Earlier grants, as principal investigator or researcher: TÜBİTAK 1501 industry R&D (P.I. Works), QNRF NPRP-Standard and NPRP-Cluster (HBKU), and NSF CNS NeTS (FIU).

Publications

Papers and preprints

1,514citations
20h-index
17journal articles
17conference papers

Google ScholarORCIDScopusWeb of Science

Citations and h-index from Google Scholar, November 2026. I publish as B. S. Ciftler.

2026

2025

  • Student Classification in Higher Education: Literature Review of Models, Approaches, and Challenges

    S. Bouallegue, A. Omri, A. Feki, R. Ford, B. S. Ciftler, A. Shikfa, S. Khan

    Scientific Culture, vol. 11, 2025

    Journal

  • Early Student Performance Prediction in Personalized Programming Education

    A. Omri, S. Bouallegue, A. Feki, R. Ford, B. S. Ciftler, A. Shikfa, S. Khan et al.

    International Conference on Education Technology and Computers (ICETC), 2025

    Conference

  • Inferring Learner Styles via Clustering of Uneven MOOC Behavioral Data

    A. Hanif, M. Albaghdadi, S. Bouallegue, A. Omri, B. S. Ciftler, A. Shikfa, S. Khan et al.

    International Conference on Education Technology and Computers (ICETC), 2025

    Conference

  • Secure and Privacy-Preserving Federated Learning-Based Resource Allocation for Next Generation Networks

    A. Dandoush, A. Gouissem, B. S. Ciftler

    ITAS 2025, Taylor & Francis, 2025

    Conference

2024

2023

2022

2021

  • AI-Based Radio Resource Allocation in Support of the Massive Heterogeneity of 6G Networks

    A. Alwarafy, A. Albaseer, B. S. Ciftler, M. Abdallah, A. Al-Fuqaha

    IEEE 4th 5G World Forum (5GWF), 2021

    Conference

  • DeepRAT: A DRL-Based Framework for Multi-RAT Assignment and Power Allocation in HetNets

    A. Alwarafy, B. S. Ciftler, M. Abdallah, M. Hamdi

    IEEE International Conference on Communications (ICC) Workshops, 2021

    Conference

  • DQN-Based Multi-User Power Allocation for Hybrid RF/VLC Networks

    B. S. Ciftler, M. Abdallah, A. Alwarafy, M. Hamdi

    IEEE International Conference on Communications (ICC), 2021

    Conference

2020

2018

2017

2016

  • Indoor Occupancy Tracking in Smart Buildings Using Passive Sniffing of Probe Requests

    E. Vattapparamban, B. S. Ciftler, K. Akkaya, A. Kadri

    IEEE International Conference on Communications (ICC) Workshops, 2016

    Conference85 citations

2015

  • Efficient Privacy-Preserving Fingerprint-Based Indoor Localization Using Crowdsourcing

    P. Armengol, R. Tobkes, K. Akkaya, B. S. Ciftler

    IEEE International Conference on Mobile Ad Hoc and Sensor Systems (MASS), 2015

    Conference

  • Experimental Performance Evaluation of Passive UHF RFID Systems Under Interference

    B. S. Ciftler, A. Kadri

    IEEE International Conference on RFID Technology and Applications (RFID-TA), 2015

    Conference

  • Fundamental Bounds on RSS-Based Wireless Localization in Passive UHF RFID Systems

    B. S. Ciftler, A. Kadri

    IEEE Wireless Communications and Networking Conference (WCNC), 2015

    Conference

2014

  • An Experimental Study on RSS-Based Wireless Localization with Software Defined Radio

    K. Vasudeva, B. S. Ciftler, A. Altamar

    IEEE Wireless and Microwave Technology Conference (WAMICON), 2014

    Conference

2013

Teaching and supervision

Concept, then code, then project

Every course I design follows the same sequence. In machine learning, I open with a deployed model that was confidently wrong and ask why nobody noticed; only then do we develop calibration and generalization.

  1. 1ConceptPlain language, and a reason to care.
  2. 2Mathematics with codeEach derivation arrives with its implementation.
  3. 3ProjectReal data, messy enough to argue back.

Supervision

  • Two M.Sc. theses as principal advisor, defending in May 2027: failure attribution in LLM-based multi-agent systems, and calibration-light brain–computer interfaces under session and subject drift, using compact models.
  • Undergraduate research that led to a DSAI student’s first-author paper at ICETC 2025 on inferring learner styles.
  • Coordinator of the DSAI industry work placement; one cohort placed 25 students with companies in Qatar and Canada.
  • At HBKU, co-supervision of M.Sc. and Ph.D. students, several of whom now hold research and faculty positions.

Most of my graduate students work full time. I break projects into increments that can survive an interruption; we meet every week and keep a written decision log.

Courses at UDST

  • DSAI 2201Introduction to Data Science and Artificial Intelligence
  • DSAI 3201Machine Learning
  • Deep Learning
  • COMP 4201Capstone Project
  • INFT 2101Networking I
  • TrainingMachine learning for faculty as well as students

Earlier teaching

  • 2020–2022Machine Learning for Wireless Network SecurityHamad Bin Khalifa University
  • 2017Computer Networks, substitute lecturerNorth Carolina State University
  • 2015–2016Wireless Digital Communications with SDR and USRP labsFlorida International University
  • 2012Telecommunications Network Optimization, graduate courseTOBB University of Economics and Technology

Leadership and service

Programmes, accreditation and institutional AI

Head of Department · since June 2023

Department of Data Science and AI, UDST

12 faculty350+ studentsABET 2026

  • Led a full redesign of the B.Sc. in Data Science and AI, contributing to more than 30 syllabi and writing more than 20 of them myself.
  • Designed two master’s programmes: the M.Sc. in AI and Cognitive Cybersecurity and the M.Sc. in Data Science and AI (2025). A third is in development.
  • Led the B.Sc. to ABET accreditation in 2026, with student-outcome assessment and an annual improvement cycle.

University-wide

University AI Committee, UDST

  • The university’s institutional AI policy was adopted under the committee.
  • A Center of Excellence in AI opened at the university.
  • Machine-learning training for faculty as well as students.

Profession

Service to the field

  • IEEE member since 2013.
  • Technical program committee, IEEE LCN 2017.
  • Organizer, Ankara Communication Seminars, for two years at TOBB ETÜ.
  • Reviewer for IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications, IEEE Internet of Things Journal, IEEE Systems Journal, IEEE Wireless Communications Letters, IEEE Communications Letters, IEEE Communications Magazine and IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, and for IEEE ICC, VTC, WCNC, GLOBECOM, INFOCOM and WAMICON.

Talks

Seminars, tutorials and workshops

Current seminar · 2026

Every Semester Is a Distribution Shift: Trustworthy AI for Personalized Programming Education

How early and how reliably can students who need support be identified, and what does it take to act on such predictions responsibly?

Read the abstract

Introductory programming courses are a well-known point of early attrition, yet signs of difficulty usually reach instructors only after major assessments, when little time remains to intervene. This talk examines how early and how reliably students who need support can be identified, and what it takes to act on such predictions responsibly, drawing on a project at the University of Doha for Science and Technology (UDST), funded by the Qatar Research, Development and Innovation Council (QRDI), on AI-driven personalized learning and gamification in programming education. Using data from 650 students in 36 class sections across two academic terms, the team developed six regression models to forecast final-exam performance from information available one month before the exam. Under nested cross-validation within a term, the best model exceeded 91% accuracy; when models trained on one term were applied to the next, the best accuracy fell to approximately 84% and the ranking of the models changed. A comparison of the two terms’ correlation structures suggests why: assessment grades became stronger predictors of the final exam, while completion-time features shifted inconsistently, some weakening and others reversing in sign. The talk argues that, in educational settings, distribution shift is a structural property rather than an exceptional event: each term introduces a new cohort, revised assessments and new tools, and an early-warning model that is not actively maintained degrades precisely where its errors are most consequential. The talk also addresses student modelling for personalization, including the inference of learning styles from uneven MOOC interaction logs without questionnaires and the characterization of students through player typology, personality, learning style and achievement emotions, together with the limits of such inferred labels. It concludes with the requirements that educational AI places on trustworthy machine learning: drift-aware evaluation and maintenance, predictions that instructors can interrogate, safeguards against unfair labelling of students, and privacy-preserving deployment.

  • 2026AI-Powered Decision Intelligence: Advanced Applications for Business LeadersExecutive education, UDST Continuing and Professional Education
  • 2023Deep reinforcement learning for resource management in 5G and beyond networksTutorial, IEEE WCNC 2023, Glasgow
  • 2023AI for the media industryFour-session workshop with the Al Jazeera Media Institute, co-presented with Dr. Ahmed Elwhishi
  • 2020Deep reinforcement learning for wireless communicationsLecture series, Hamad Bin Khalifa University
  • 2018Machine learning for engineeringLecture series, Yıldız Technical University

Short bio for organizers

Read the bio

Bekir Sait Çiftler is an Assistant Professor and Head of the Department of Data Science and Artificial Intelligence in the College of Computing and Information Technology at the University of Doha for Science and Technology (UDST), Qatar. His research concerns trustworthy and efficient artificial intelligence, with a focus on keeping machine learning systems reliable after deployment: distribution shift and model maintenance, small and efficient language models, and runtime assurance for LLM-based agents. His earlier work spans federated and privacy-preserving learning, deep reinforcement learning for resource management in wireless networks, and indoor localization for the Internet of Things. His publications have received more than 1,500 citations, and he contributes to research funded by the Qatar Research, Development and Innovation Council. At UDST, he led the redesign of the B.Sc. in Data Science and Artificial Intelligence and its ABET accreditation, designed two master’s programmes, and served on the University AI Committee at UDST, under which the institutional AI policy and a Center of Excellence in AI were established. Before joining UDST in 2022, he was a postdoctoral research fellow at Hamad Bin Khalifa University and a machine learning solution architect in industry. He holds a Ph.D. in Electrical and Computer Engineering from Florida International University, and M.Sc. and B.Sc. degrees in Electrical and Electronics Engineering from TOBB University of Economics and Technology and Middle East Technical University, respectively.

About

From wireless positioning to trustworthy AI

I trained as an electrical engineer in Ankara, at METU and TOBB ETÜ, and completed my Ph.D. at Florida International University in Miami, working on wireless positioning and tracking for the Internet of Things. Research visits took me to the Qatar Mobility Innovations Center in Doha, Mitsubishi Electric Research Laboratories in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and North Carolina State University.

After my Ph.D., I spent two years in Istanbul as a machine learning solution architect at P.I. Works, building machine learning tools for telecom network management and leading a TÜBİTAK-funded industry R&D project. I returned to research as a postdoctoral research fellow at Hamad Bin Khalifa University, working on federated learning, security and deep reinforcement learning, and joined UDST in 2022. I have led its Department of Data Science and AI since 2023.

Outside the university, I advise government bodies and companies on AI programmes. In Turkish, I run Veri Bilinci, an initiative on data and AI literacy, which also has a YouTube channel.

I have lived in İskenderun, Şanlıurfa, Kayseri, Ankara, Istanbul, Miami, Boston, Raleigh and Doha. I work in Turkish and English, and I am improving my Arabic.

Education

  • 2017Ph.D., Electrical and Computer Engineering, Florida International UniversityDissertation: Wireless Positioning and Tracking for Internet of Things in GPS-Denied Environments.
  • 2013M.Sc., Electrical and Electronics Engineering, TOBB University of Economics and TechnologyThesis on key pool size and secret-key encryption in wireless sensor networks. Advisor: Bülent Tavlı.
  • 2011B.Sc., Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Middle East Technical University

Positions

  • 2023–todayHead, Department of Data Science and AI, UDSTCurriculum, ABET accreditation, faculty recruitment and partnerships for a department of 12 faculty and 350+ students.
  • 2022–todayAssistant Professor, UDST, DohaTeaching, supervision and research in data science and AI.
  • 2019–todayAI strategy and solution advisor, Qatar and internationalConfidential AI programmes for national government bodies and companies in broadcast media, aviation, telecommunications and financial services.
  • 2019–2022Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Hamad Bin Khalifa University, DohaFederated learning, security and deep reinforcement learning. Developed two QNRF proposals that were awarded.
Earlier positions
  • 2017–2019Machine Learning Solution Architect, P.I. Works, IstanbulML research projects at a global telecom network-management vendor; principal investigator of a TÜBİTAK 1501 industry R&D project.
  • 2016–2017Visiting Research Assistant, North Carolina State UniversityIoT localization in GPS-denied environments and UAV navigation with reinforcement learning, on NSF-funded projects.
  • 2016Junior Visiting Researcher, Mitsubishi Electric Research Laboratories, Cambridge, MAML-based indoor localization and occupancy detection.
  • 2013–2016Research and Teaching Assistant, Florida International UniversityIndoor positioning and software-defined-radio implementation on NSF-funded projects; USRP lab sessions.
  • 2014, 2015Visiting Research Assistant, Qatar Mobility Innovations Center, DohaUHF RFID localization and USRP-based ranging experiments.
  • 2011–2013Graduate Assistant, TOBB ETÜ, AnkaraTaught a graduate course on telecommunications network optimization and organized the Ankara Communication Seminars.

Contact

Get in touch

I am glad to hear from prospective students, research collaborators, and organizations looking for advice, training or a talk on AI.

Students

I take M.Sc. students and undergraduate researchers in trustworthy and efficient AI. Send your CV and a paragraph on the problem you want to work on.

Researchers

I collaborate on detecting and mitigating drift in deployed models, small language models, assurance for LLM agents, federated learning and AI in education.

Organizations

I advise on AI strategy and delivery, and teach executive sessions on AI for decision-makers.

Research

More

Filters